Best Cookie Press 2023: 5+ Detailed Reviews

Top 5 Best Cookie Presses 2023:

1. Oxo Good Grips Cookie Press
2. Wilton Preferred Cookie Press
3. Marcato 8307RD Atlas Deluxe Biscuit Maker
4. Cuisinart CTG-00-CP Cookie Press
5. Wilton Cookie Master Plus Electric Cookie Press

When it comes to cookies, there are two kinds of people – those who like to eat them and those who like to make them. 

No matter which group you belong to, you’ll probably want to get a cookie press. Eaters can buy it as a gift for makers and, by doing so, invest in their cookie-eating future. The best part of the story is that both parties will be happy.

You’d be wrong to think that a cookie press is just something you go out and buy at the supermarket. Au contraire! It takes a fair bit of consideration to choose a good one, but don’t worry; we’re going to help you do it.  

Enter the best cookie press roundup of this year – the most delicious article on the internet!

---

5 Best Cookie Presses In 2023: Detailed Reviews

While exploring the “cookieverse”, we discovered that there are many, many cookie presses out there; some of them are as different as night and day. How is a man (or woman) to pick just one model from such a diverse offer?

Luckily for you, we funneled it all down to five top-notch cookie presses, and you can read about them in the review section!

1. Oxo Good Grips Cookie Press – Best Overall

If you’re the kind of person who likes to skip the fuss and get straight to the point, then Oxo is the cookie press for you. No need to read about the rest (although they’re great in their way too). Enough messin’ around; let’s talk about Oxo Good Grips!

This model’s got it all – the ease of use, great price, and a whole lot of versatility. It is lightweight, so kids can handle it without any problems. Another great thing about it is the so-called “No-Stress Press”, i.e., the lever used to press the dough out. It makes the whole process effortless as it requires much less “manpower” than many of its counterparts.

The maintenance is as simple as it gets. The press can be disassembled into three parts, and none of them have any tricky spots where the dough might get stuck. The metal disks are dishwasher-safe, so you don’t have to bother scrubbing them by hand.

Speaking of discs, you’ll get plenty of them; twelve, to be precise. They feature various shapes like flowers, snowflakes, etc. and they all come neatly arranged in a plastic box.

Now, the main trouble with Oxo is its fragility, so be careful not to drop it. Aside from this, we don’t have any complaints about this cookie press!

2. Wilton Preferred Cookie Press – Most Ergonomic Cookie Press

In case you liked Oxo but decided to keep on reading, then you’re in luck because Wilton Preferred cookie press is quite similar. If comfort is what you’re looking for, then comfort you shall find with this one.

As we said, this press resembles Oxo in terms of design and the press mechanism. It doesn’t have a syringe-like plunger, but a handle mounted on the side. However, unlike Oxo’s model, you don’t press the handle down, but you pull it up like a gun’s trigger. 

So yeah, Wilton is all about that squeezing action, but the important part is that it doesn’t require much effort. You may run into problems when working with very thick dough, as it’ll be harder to get it out, and that’s the biggest flaw of this design.

When it comes to the metal disks, there are twelve of them in the package. They mostly feature abstract shapes and just a few non-abstract ones (sun, flower, and tree). 

The transparent cylinder lets you see exactly how much dough you’ve got left. When you run out of cookie material, don’t worry, refilling is made easy thanks to the large opening on top.

All in all, Wilton is a great cookie press, but be ready to pay a few bucks more for it.

3. Marcato 8307RD Atlas Deluxe Biscuit Maker – Most Durable Cookie Press

Hailing from Italy, Marcato’s 8370RD Atlas Deluxe biscuit maker will give you the authentic biscotti-making experience – just like nonna used to make ‘em. 

However, we don’t like to buy things based on nostalgia, and neither should you! This cookie maker is excellent, and that’s the main reason it ended up on our list.

The selling point of this cookie press is its sturdy stainless-steel construction. You’ll be able to use all the force you need and press out even the thickest of doughs without worrying about breaking something. 

The cylinder is elegantly curved, making it easy to hold and move around. To press out the dough, just push the metal lever down, and this will be easy or difficult, depending on the consistency of the cookie batter.

The trouble with 8307RD is that it’s non-transparent, so you can’t see how much filling you have left. Also, since it’s made from metal, it’s heavier than plastic models and might make you tired more quickly.

As for the extras, you’ll get twenty discs with traditional cookie shapes and a 10-year warranty, which is certainly a nice addition.

Folks who are looking for a model that’s built to last will probably be happy with this one.

4. Cuisinart CTG-00-CP Cookie Press – Best Budget Cookie Press

Those interested in spending as little money as possible and still getting a decent cookie press should take a look at Cuisinart CTG-00-CP. A reputable manufacturer usually means good quality even in case of low prices, and we found this to be true with CTG-00-CP.

First off, the product is made mostly from plastic, but it has a metal press, which adds to the over quality. The gun-like mechanism will definitely entertain many users, and kids will find it exceptionally fun.

Second, the press comes with eighteen discs and six tips all made of – you guessed it – plastic. Now, this will probably annoy many customers with (justified) durability concerns, but it is what it is. A little piece of advice – don’t squeeze it too hard and don’t put the ultra-thick dough in it, and you should be fine.

Third, we’ve got some good news for you; the press and all of its parts are dishwasher-safe. This means no scrubbing or soaking, or none of that nasty work unless you want to, of course.

Last, this is the cheapest cookie press on the list, and simultaneously the best bang for your buck. It’s highly unlikely to find this kind of quality for the same amount of money.

5. Wilton Cookie Master Plus Electric Cookie Press – Best Electric Cookie Press

If you prefer electric over manual power, then do check out Wilton Cookie Master Plus cookie press. This unit doesn’t require any hard muscle work, and all that’s needed to get things going is a press of a button.

Made from high-quality plastic, this little device is surprisingly durable. Its size is roughly the same as the other products we mentioned, so it’s nothing out of the ordinary.

Since this is an electric cookie press, it has no levers or plungers sticking out, which makes it more compact than most manual models. There’s a button that you press with your thumb as you grip the handle, and the dough will come out.

This is a battery-powered device, so you need to make sure to have spare batteries lying around at all times. The good part is that you won’t have to bother with cables, which means easier maneuvering.

The biggest setback of Wilton’s cookie press is the lack of power to press out the thick dough. To be fair, this is a common problem with electric presses in general, so be aware of that before buying. Oh yeah, we almost forgot – these things aren’t cheap either!

---

What Is A Cookie Press?

For those who don’t know what the hell we’re talking about today, a cookie press is a device for squirting out dough onto a baking dish and making spritz cookies. It consists of a large cylinder with a plunger on one end and a small hole on the other. 

To use it, simply fill it up with cookie dough, press the plunger, and voila – the cookie-shaped dough comes out through the hole. You can also get creative and use perforated plates with various shapes (star, moon, etc.) to make interesting-looking bites. 

---

What To Know Before Buying A Cookie Press?

Like we said earlier, buying a cookie press isn’t exactly a walk in the park, not if you want to get a decent model. However, it’s not difficult either as all you have to do is learn about some key features and choose a cookie press based on them.

What are those features exactly? Take a look below to find out.

1. Ergonomics And Ease Of Use

Making cookies should be fun, but some cookie presses seem like they were designed for the opposite. Nothing can ruin your perfect cookie-making afternoon like bad press, so pay close attention to the following paragraphs.

First, consider how easy or hard it is to pour the dough into the cylinder. Certain presses have a narrow hole or some other design flaw that could make this process irritating. Avoid such models at all costs and get one with a nice big opening for the dough.

Next, if possible, look for a lightweight device. This is especially important if you like to involve kids in the process. Another thing to think about is the amount of effort needed to press out the dough. Your best bet is to see what the previous users have to say about this before picking a press.

2. Maintenance 

Ease of maintenance is an essential factor, and not just because of fuss-free cleaning, but because of hygiene and your health as well.

When looking for a model that’s simple to maintain, it’s crucial not to focus just on the cylinder, but on all the bits and pieces that make the press. Look for something without many nooks or crevices, as it’ll be troublesome to scratch the dough out of those spots.

Also, all the parts should be easily accessible, meaning that it shouldn’t be challenging to take the press apart (and put it back together). 

Make sure to check the manufacturer’s cleaning guidelines as well as customer comments regarding this.

3. Electric Or Manual

In case you didn’t know, there are electric-powered cookie presses too. Amazing, right? Such models require no muscle power, and all you need is a light push of a button to press the dough out. 

But, it’s not all fun and games with electric models. 

They (obviously) need a power source, either an outlet or batteries, both of which have their pros and cons. Besides this, many such presses simply don’t have the power to push out really thick dough. 

Manual presses will give you more versatility when it comes to dough consistency and is generally seen as more durable. On top of this, manual models are also cheaper.

We leave the choice up to you.

4. Extras

Some cookie presses come with neat accessories that can mean a lot for those who like to get creative. These extras are mostly plates or discs with different-shaped holes that let you prepare cookies that look great 

On top of this, you can get tips or extensions that narrow down the hole where the dough comes out, so this might interest some users too. The amount of accessories varies from model to model, so be sure to check it out for every cookie press that you look at.

5. Capacity

The cylinder size determines how much dough you’ll be able to place in it, and how many cookies you can squeeze out with a single fill. This is important for folks who make large batches as they won’t have to refill very often. In case you’re a professional baker, get as large a capacity as possible!

---

Conclusion

Cookie fanatics, sugar addicts, and those who love homemade goods, we’d like to thank you for joining us today. 

It’s been a great ride, and we hope you enjoyed reading about the cookie presses as much as we enjoyed writing about them. Before we leave you, here are our top three models from the list.

The first place goes to Oxo Good Grips Cookie Press, as we believe it is the most well-rounded cookie press on the market. It’s got decent build quality, ergonomic design, it’s easy to use, and won’t cost you a lot. This device is a cookie lover’s dream!

Wilton Preferred Cookie Press takes the silver medal today, as it’s got all the qualities of a top-notch cookie press. This model is for those who enjoy the squeezing motion more and who are especially concerned about the ease of refilling.

Our third pick is the Marcato 8307RD Atlas Deluxe, biscuit maker. This press is in a category of its own regarding durability and builds quality. Its stainless-steel construction guarantees longevity, but you’ll have to pay a bit more for it.

That’d be all for today, folks. Until next time – bake on!