Best Toaster Oven 2023: 5+ Detailed Reviews

Top 5 Best Toaster Ovens 2023:

Compact, convenient, and energy-saving, toaster ovens are a bonus to any kitchen. Bake up a tray of chocolate chip cookies in a flash. Broil the perfect steak with a side of potatoes for a quick and tasty meal. Do it all without heating up your entire kitchen or your wallet either.

For all their convenience and value, finding the best toaster oven can be a daunting task. There are many makes and models out there. Some with features that are absolute must-haves. Others with more focus on style than versatility. With many options to choose from, we’ve compiled this guide to review for you the best of the best toaster ovens.

Read on and let us give you the ‘slice by slice’ on what to look for when buying one of these compact cookers!

5 Best Toaster Ovens In 2023: Detailed Reviews

1. Black and Decker Countertop Toaster Oven CTO6335S

First in our best countertop cooker ovens roundup is the Black and Decker CTO6335S Toaster Oven. This oven can accommodate many different foods. From bagels to pizza to frozen dinners – the CTO6335S countertop toaster can conveniently cook them all. With a large capacity, this appliance is a winner when it comes to serving up bigger dinners.

The Black and Decker Countertop Toaster oven has dimensions measuring 22.8×13.4×15.5. While it is a countertop style, this unit is lightweight and easily moved. The size gives it a leg up in allowing for easy storage. While in use, the space needed is very comparable to the rest on our list.

This compact oven features convection heating as well as broiling. It comes with a 13×9 bake pan, a removable broiler pan for easy cleanup and cooking as well as an external crumb tray. The crumb tray slides in and out for quick access. The oven includes dual-position racks too. This means you can place items right under the broiler for the perfect crisp finish.

The interior is non-stick and easy to clean. The finish allows for a no-hassle wipe down of even sticky messes.

This cooker comes with 8 one-touch functions for your favorite items, including cookies. These preset allow for a worry-free cooking experience and control.

When reviewing the display, this oven leaves something to be desired. While it is an LED display, it’s not backlit. This makes it difficult to read without the help of another light.

Pros

Larger capacity
Lightweight
8 one-touch presets

External slide crumb tray

Cons

Inadequately lit display

2. Oster Large Convection Toaster Oven

Second in our roundup is the Oster Digital Convection Toaster Oven. This unit can fit a 2×10.5×12.5 pan or 6 slices of bread easily. With that in mind, it can accommodate various foods, from pizzas to meat roasts and more.

This appliance offers two rack positions for even cooking. The duel positions are designed to give you the ability to cook taller roasts or a whole chicken.

The Oster Large Convection Toaster oven is measured at 19.72×16.29×11.33 with a 31.5-inch cord. The interior space allows for larger food items to be cooked evenly. While not the largest for capacity, the Oster does hold its own place in this category.

This cooker comes with a durable baking pan and removable crumb tray. It also has 7 cooking settings and an interior light. The Oster oven uses convection cooking with a range of 150-450 degrees. The circulation of hot air with confection gives flakier crusts and crisp edges.

This unit allows for broiling at various degrees for the perfect browning. It can even gently melt delicate cheese. In addition, the digital one-touch panel is easy to read and user-friendly. Choose from many different cooking options – from bake to broil to toast and more.

The Oster toaster oven comes with a 90 min timer. It automatically shuts off for worry-free cooking. Also, the interior light offers a bright illumination. It also has a fair-sized viewing glass door so you can monitor your food as it cooks.

Using foil in this oven can cause it to heat up over 500 degrees – this will contribute to severe overheating. In addition to this, the Oster Large Convection Toaster oven’s exterior has can become very hot when in use. While stainless steel is great for easy cleaning, the outside finish conducts heat and could cause injury. As with any heating appliance caution should be used. However, in the case of Oster, overheating is a definite deterrent when considering purchasing.

Pros

Long power cord
Multiple cook settings
Dual-position rack

Large capacity

Cons

Potential for overheating with aluminum foil
Exterior gets very hot to the touch when in use

3. Cuisinart TOA-60 Convection Toaster Oven and Air Fryer

Capable and convenient with a retro vibe of style, the Cuisinart TOA toaster oven is our third-place contender. This 6-slice sized competitor offers stainless steel finished exterior and has a large opening and tall interior to provide spacious cooking.

While not the largest when it comes to capacity for our best toaster ovens, the TOA-60 countertop cooker is a winner for design and overall style. Also, this oven has a steel basket, unlike our other toaster ovens. The basket can be removed to accommodate pizza or other dinner items.

This oven also gives the option of air frying. Air frying is a healthy cooking option. It also gives you a crisp finish to French fries and other favorite fried foods.

The dimensions of this countertop appliance are 14” by 15.8” by 14”. This toaster oven is designed for stationary use only. At 21lbs, it’s no wonder as moving this oven can be inconvenient for some.

Besides the weight, another downside of this is that it uses up prime countertop real estate. For those with small kitchens, this oven isn’t the best option.

The Cuisinart TOA-60 Toaster Oven includes an adjustable oven rack and baking pan. It also has an air fryer basket rack as previously mentioned. The turn-style dials give off a very retro vibe and are easy to use.

This oven has an adjustable thermostat too. It provides a 60min timer with an auto shut-off. In addition, there is a toast shade selector for the perfect toast, convection bake feature, and broil as well.

Pros

Air fry feature
Stylish design

Multiple accessories

Cons

Stationary countertop – takes up prime kitchen space
Heavy model to move if needed

4. Mueller 4 Slice Toaster Oven

Our fourth finalist for the best countertop cooker is The Muller 4 Slice Toaster Oven. This model is a compact oven with a square design. It provides great heating and baking as well as broiling – all in a smaller package.

The Mueller 4 Slice Toaster Oven only allows for 4 slices of bread or a 9-inch pizza as compared to the others on our list. This smaller capacity makes it a no-go for those with larger families or for big events.

The plus for being smaller is that this unit is very energy-efficient. It heats or reheats 30% faster than most other ovens. While doing this, it uses 60% less energy. It has a dual-position rack that can be taken out for easy cleanup. The exterior and interior are stainless steel.

The Mueller 4 Slice Toaster Oven comes in at 17.1×13.9×11.5 for dimensions. This makes it one of the smaller units on our list of best toaster ovens. It is lightweight and can be easily stored away for later use.

This appliance has a large front view window and very easy-to-read turn dials. It also comes with a removable rack and baking pan.

Other models on our list of best compact countertop cookers come with over 90 mins of auto timing. Unfortunately, the Mueller only offers a 25 min auto timer. This makes it one of the last to place timer features in our guide.

Pros

Energy efficient
Large front viewing window
Dual-position racking

Cons

Smaller capacity
Short built-in timer

5. Panasonic FlashXpress Compact Toaster Oven

Our final competitor in search of the best countertop toaster ovens is the Panasonic FlashXpress Compact Toaster Oven. This model is the smallest oven in our buyer’s guide. Its square design is wide enough for a 9-inch pizza or 4 average slices of bread. While the style is quite retro, it certainly isn’t the top choice for size when it comes to big dinners.

At 12x13x10.25 for dimensions – the Panasonic FlashXpress won’t take up much countertop space. It is also very lightweight for quick and simple storage.

This unit uses infrared heating to cook. As such, it is the only one featured on our list that offers this. It has quartz and ceramic heating elements at the front and back. These elements provide quite even cooking.

With elements like that, the oven doesn’t require any type of preheating – it can be used right away. The FlashXpress also has 6 auto-cook options. The pre-programmed features are easy to use.

In addition, this model of the oven comes with an interior light, a removable crumb tray, and an auto-eject feature. The eject feature pulls the tray out as you open the door. The auto-eject gives quick access to your food and means less chance of being burned.

The display is not the most stylish to look at. The icons are overly simplistic and the design is very retro. The temp setting option and timer display are not as easily read either. It also comes with a short auto timer of only 25 mins. This means checking on your food more frequently.

Pros

Infrared heating with no preheating required

Auto eject tray
Lightweight

Cons

Small capacity

Overly simplistic display
25min auto timer
Very small front view window

The Crumb Of It – More On Toaster Ovens

Using a toaster oven for quick meals is a great option for many reasons. They provide all the heating of a conventional oven without the hassle of a large appliance. They use up less energy than your average oven as well. This means more savings for you.

As with any appliance that uses heat, caution should be taken when using a toaster oven. These countertop cookers don’t expel as much heat as their larger cousins, but still, get hot. Some can produce a lot of external heat to the touch. That being the case, always make sure you take proper precautions when using these ovens.

In addition, always keep your toaster ovens out of reach of children. You should also make sure these appliances are properly stationed on your counter. We recommend your toaster oven is set up far enough away from other appliances and the wall. This will prevent damage and also help to dissipate heat. Proper heat dissipation will ensure your toaster oven is in prime working condition.

What Makes A Toaster Oven The “Best”?

We’ve narrowed down what important things to look for in the best toaster oven. While convenience with quick-cooking type appliances is easily the top feature – there are other options to consider. Here are the main values of our best countertop ovens.

1. Capacity

When looking at an appliance to cook meals, what and how much you can cook is important. How large or small of a capacity your toaster oven has is a vital feature. If you are a single person in a small apartment, a small unit would work great. A simple and quick personal pan pizza is easily baked with less energy consumption in a toaster oven. If you have a big family, look at a unit that gives more space inside for larger meals.

Stationary countertop ovens offer great capacity and deep space. More interior space means larger meals and more food options. For families with big appetites or many mouths to feed, a larger toaster oven is more suitable.

In either case – big or small – careful consideration of what you cook and what space you have is a must with toaster ovens.

2. Dimensions

Gone are the days of bulky appliances and cluttered countertops. Size matters. If you want to maximize your kitchen countertop real estate, look into a smaller dimension toaster oven. Consider one that is also lightweight. This will allow you to easily store and move it as needed.

If you have plenty of countertop area, a stationary model of a toaster oven will work great. Keep in mind the safe operation of units like this and place them carefully. Open space between walls and other appliances is always recommended.

3. Features And Accessories

If you are looking to use a toaster oven to replace larger appliances, features are vital. You want to do more than just reheat or bake.

The best toaster ovens we list here offer many preset cooking menus for easy cooking. They also have removable cooking trays and one-touch options too. Make sure you consider what type of food you will be cooking so the features offered in your oven match.

A Toast To The Best Toaster Oven

Whether it’s family night or singles only – toaster ovens are a great alternative to large appliances. They consume less energy, generate less heat, and are easy to use.

Features like large viewing windows as on The Muller 4 Slice Toaster Oven give you the ability to check on your food. Quick and immediate cooking like with the Panasonic FlashXpress Compact Toaster Oven allows you to have food ready in a flash.

Multiple preset menus are convenient meal helpers. They offer worry-free cooking for perfectly baked pizza or fresh cookies.

Accessories are valuable assets too. Removable crumb pans for easy clean-up make keeping things tidy a breeze. Auto eject options give fast access to food with less chance of burns.

Finding the best toaster oven for you and your family’s needs is made easier with our guide. We’ve provided value for money and what to look for in the perfect countertop cooking oven. So make your next meal an easy one. Pop in a pizza and let the toasting begin! For deliciousness and convenience, all rolled into one compact package, pick up the best toaster oven today!

For more fantastic guides and articles, like and share our “best of” listings and make shopping an easy and breezy experience!